Resume Virtues versus Eulogy Virtues
I have nothing snide to say about the following. I thought it was interesting and kind of sad. It should make you want to teach PSR
From Maggie Gallagher and the National Review article, "Why Are Palo Alto Kids Killing Themselves?"
Stress in itself is not what causes people misery, anxiety, or
depression, and fun is not what keeps people from wanting to kill
themselves.
Listening to these voices made me think again of David Brooks’s astute
comment that there are the Résumé Virtues and the Eulogy Virtues. The
résumé virtues are what create success in status competitions. The
eulogy virtues are what gives meaning to life in the face of the
inevitability of that ultimate failure, death...
The elite Creative Class in America prides itself mostly on its
brains, and the amazing things that, with hard work and perseverance,
one can contribute to the world through intelligence; all true and good
as far as it goes. That is why elite parents try so hard to pass on
their class advantages to their children through relentless development
of their little human capital, from violin lessons to SAT tutoring. It
is the same reason why so many elite stay-at-home mothers I know value
their own mothering to the extent it produces daughters who succeed in
the world of education and work. My daughter’s getting into Harvard
validates my mothering. We seemed to have turned our very children into
résumé virtues. To be a B student is to become a B human being.
None of us would say that out loud to our children, or even to
ourselves. But the gods of the résumé virtues are relentless and
unforgiving, unless their godlike status is contested, unless there is a
world outside of work and achievement, some other definition of being
human and worthy of love, some glimpse of the human soul.
<< Home